Monday, November 30, 2020

III.2. THE EAST, WHERE NEW WORLDS EMERGE

MENU: 3.2. The east: New worlds appear
 
THE TRAGIC PAST AND MODERN ENERGY MIX

These pages concentrate on the former villages of Belleville and Ménilmontant, but creativity springs up all over the east. 

# # #


Urban transformation forced laborers to move from the center to distant heights...
(In the mid-1850's)
Zoom

Where they threatened elites again.


Building barricades when the Paris Commune breaks out.

 Opposition lives on.

Street art on a truck and "police" written upside down.

Highlights of one of the city's
most ebullient places
*     *     *

Next,





Sunday, November 29, 2020

MEMORIES OF INSURRECTION

  

LA COMMUNE THEN, SOME OF ITS SITES NOW


MEETINGS LIKE THIS TOOK PLACE... 

Musée Carnavalet, not exhibited
In this church...

Notre-Dame de la Croix, Ménilmontant / zoom

On streets of ferocious combat:

  • Rue de Belleville:

  Daniel Vierge in Ma Commune de Paris / zoom
  • Rue de Ménilmontant

Who were those men from la Creuse who fought and fell during the Commune of 1871?
"La Montagne," 2021 (a journal of central France; this page now gone)

# # #

Now
this Kurdish restaurant faces street and church. 
Behind the church is this progressive bookstore, where conversations take place after books are presented:

   Chez les Deux Amis Gourmet
110 rue de Ménilmontant

3 rue de la Mare 



# # #

La Commune is in the neighborhood's DNA.

Saturday, November 28, 2020

PRELIMINARY FRACAS: THE MAD "DESCENT FROM LA COURTILLE"


"LA DÉCENTE" WAS A WILD CORTEGE THAT SWEPT DOWN FROM BELLEVILLE TO PARIS'S CITY HALL ON ASH WEDNESDAYS
AT DAWN
(FROM THE 1820'S TO THE EARLY 1860'S)

That is, from underclass outskirts to the heart of the bourgeois town, in defiance of Church demand for penance.

            Plan of 1756 / zoom (please scroll down)

Descente de La Courtille by Charles Nanteuil, 1842 / zoom
The Carnavalet Museum has not exhibited the work since the renovation that focusses on elites

# # #
 
At its origin were custom duties on wares coming into town, collected from a new city wall. Taverns that sold untaxed wine sprang up outside the its gates.
(From 1788)

       L'octroi [toll gate] de Belleville by J.-L.-G.-B. Palaiseau, toward 1790, zoom

    Le Cabaret Ramponeau en Bas Courtille vers 1761, anonymous / zoom
The tavern where wine was cheapest

# # #

They brought a counter-culture. The cancan was part of it.  

  • Called the "La dance des barrières,"* the cancan is the only French dance that women lead. Its exuberant sexuality and steps that taunt authority made it forbidden in Paris: For an example of its provocation, please click and scroll down.

*Barrières
toll gates

  • A best-selling novel of 1848 reveals its transgressive nature:  

  
                             Les Mystères de Paris by Eugène Sue, 1848

Dancers warm up before going to a southern barrière (near today's Saint-Jacques métro) to watch two women be guillotined. When the "cannibals" rush off to the execution, the hero, a prince on horseback, breaks up their crowd.


The "Descent from la Courtille"* was another mocking challenge.

*Courtille: a small court in front of a farm, the original name of the Belleville crossroads.

  •  After carousing in the taverns all night, the costumed and drunk residents would march down the hill to Paris. Slumming party-goers would join the cortège, or rent windows to watch it pass.

                    La Bibliothèque historique de Paris, Facebook, with no more information

# # #

The procession reveals class hostility long before conflict breaks out: 

  • Lent, the six weeks before celebrating Christ's Resurrection at Easter, is for Catholics a time of fasting and abstinence. It begins on with a priest drawing a cross with ashes on the foreheads of the faithful as a sign of penitence, on Ash Wednesday.

Strasbourg, 2014 / zoom

  • Mardi Gras ("Fat Tuesday") takes place just before Ash Wednesday. The license tolerated then contrasts with the austerity to come.

 New Orleans, 2011 / zoom

By deliberately holding the cortège not during Mardi Gras but in the first hours of Ash Wednesday, La Descente provoked the Church, ally of the elite.

#  #  #

In 1860 the State moved the city limits to the distant fortifications. That brought the turbulent outskirts under its control, letting the police arrest rebels who took refuge there. 

             Adapted from Fortifications of Paris and its Environs, 1841, zoom

     The Good Town of Paris and its New Children by Charles Vernier, 1850 / zoom

The benevolent Government scrubs La Villette (whose residents had particularly resisted the take-over) while Belleville wipes his nose with his hand and Bercy, where wine was stored, drinks straight from the bottle. 

Only the well-dressed girl behaves properly. But she is from Batignolles, in the prosperous west.

Moving the toll barriers ended the taverns and so La Descente.

# # #

Industrialisation would have stopped it in any case
because it gave the poor less leisure and less pay,
but pushing back the toll gates hastened its demise.

Tuesday, November 24, 2020

TOWARD THE BELLEVILLE CROSSROAD NOW


WALK DOWN TO THE JUNCTION WHERE "LA DESCENTE" BEGAN
(BY RUE DE BELLEVILLE)

Adapted from a Google map



Traces of old Belleville: Edith Piaf and Marcel Arnault



"On the steps of this house on December 19, 1915 in the greatest poverty was born Édith Piaf, whose voice would shake the world."

That she was born on the steps is a myth, but Piaf's parents did live in that house, she did sing in this street and she was so poor that she had to prostitute herself to bury her two-year old child. 


From the 1920's to the 1970's, Armenians and Eastern European Jews made Belleville France's center for handmade shoes. Among the rare French cobblers was Michel Arnault, whose workshop was next to that house:


He told the biographer his story as he worked away, nails in his mouth. Too ill to go to school, he learned to read and write with clients in cafés. Then he read and pondered great philosophers and writers. 

When during the Occupation 
the police prepared to arrest Arnault's Jewish assistant...

a friend persuaded a French official to meet him. Things began badly, the official saying that the Gestapo had the dossier already. Arnault was so tense that he tore the petals away from a flower in a vase on the table, murmuring a Latin declension (rosa, rosa, rosam...). The official asked if he knew Latin, and in the affirmative tested him by reciting Caesar's commentaries in the original. The conversation continued in Latin, and the assistant was saved.

More on Arnault here.
# # #

Another "Chinatown," which is newer and smaller than that of the 13th:

 

An Asian chorus at a Fête de la Musique

# # #

On the way to the crossroad



  Jaber



A café for music and slam
Culture rapide
103 rue Julien Lecroix (corner rue de Belleville)


Street art






# # #

At the intersection where was once La Courtille, 
a sign lists the taverns and mentions La Descente...
leaving out its subversion.
Street art is in the background.

At the crossroad, turn left.