Saturday, November 14, 2015

AN INTELLIGENT OGRE CHECKS IN


ADOLPHE THIERS WAS CENTRAL TO THE FRENCH RIGHT FOR ALMOST HALF A CENTURY
(FROM THE 1830 REVOLUTION TO HIS DEATH IN 1877)

An appalling figure who in some ways deserves respect.
-- A balanced biography:
Thiers, bourgeois et révolutionnaire by Georges Valence


An erudite, lively, honest historian, his books on John Law, the Revolution and Napoleon are still read:


"After 15 years of arduous work I have just finished
History of the Consulate and Empire"

"One could, I agree, work more quickly, but I have such respect for the mission of history that the fear of announcing a fact that is inaccurate fills me with a kind of confusion. Then I cannot rest till I have been able to prove the object of my doubt. I seek it wherever it may be, and do not stop until I have found it, or come to the certainty that it does not exist. 

In that case 
[... ] I state my intimate conviction, but always with the extreme fear of error, for I find that when one has undertaken to tell the truth of great events, there is nothing worse [...] than to disguise by weakness, to alter by passion, and to lie, consciously or not, to one's own time and to times to come."
-- Translation and bolding mine


He overcomes obstacles that should have been crippling. At a time when...

  • Family origins are fundamental, his family is not only indigent but dishonored: His father blackmails him and his brother is a known deserter and agent provocateur. He helps both.
  • Physical presence and oratory are also essentiel but Theirs is so short that his legs barely encircle a horse, while at the Assembly his disagreeably high-pitched voice can hardly be heard.
  • Urbanity is indispensable, he shows off his newly-acquired wealth like the parvenu he is.

Work, intelligence and Marseilles blarney explain his success:

  • He founds the first Opposition newspaper at the end of the 1820's, writes the call that launches the 1830 Revolution, persuades Louis-Philippe to accede to the throne and holds the highest positions during that reign.

  • As head of the conservative opposition he is jailed after Napoleon III's coup d'état and for most of the Second Empire (1851-1870) is retired. He returns to politics as a deputy (in 1868) and is one of the few to oppose the Franco-Prussian war (in July 1870).

  • That lucidity leads to his heading the Third Republic when the Empire implodes (in September 1870). He becomes its President, and holds that position until his death.

But he also... 

  • Commands the brutal repression of a silk workers' revolt in Lyons, France's second largest city (in 1834):


"Let them fire the first shot. Then let them have it." Six hundred people are killed, almost all workers.

  • Orders crushing the Parisian revolt that follows, accompanying the troops himself:

Internet without more information

Advises the commander of the "June" carnage (in 1848):


Internet without more information

  • Inspires this image, where with one foot in the grave he asks Death to wait while he bombards Paris under La Commune:


"O death! Wait a minute more!"


Thiers leads or contributes to
all the massacres of his times except that 
following Napoleon III's take-over in 1851,
when he is in prison. 

No comments: