Showing posts with label 5.2.8. An intelligent ogre checks in. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 5.2.8. An intelligent ogre checks in. Show all posts

Saturday, November 14, 2015

AN INTELLIGENT OGRE CHECKS IN


ADOLPHE THIERS WAS CENTRAL TO THE FRENCH RIGHT FOR ALMOST HALF A CENTURY
(FROM THE 1830 REVOLUTION TO HIS DEATH IN 1877)

An appalling figure who in some ways deserves respect.
-- A balanced biography:
Thiers, bourgeois et révolutionnaire by Georges Valence


An erudite, lively, honest historian, his books on John Law, the Revolution and Napoleon are still read:


"After 15 years of arduous work I have just finished
History of the Consulate and Empire"

"One could, I agree, work more quickly, but I have such respect for the mission of history that the fear of announcing a fact that is inaccurate fills me with a kind of confusion. Then I cannot rest till I have been able to prove the object of my doubt. I seek it wherever it may be, and do not stop until I have found it, or come to the certainty that it does not exist. 

In that case 
[... ] I state my intimate conviction, but always with the extreme fear of error, for I find that when one has undertaken to tell the truth of great events, there is nothing worse [...] than to disguise by weakness, to alter by passion, and to lie, consciously or not, to one's own time and to times to come."
-- Translation and bolding mine


He overcomes obstacles that should have been crippling. At a time when...

  • Family origins are fundamental, his family is not only indigent but dishonored: His father blackmails him and his brother is a known deserter and agent provocateur. He helps both.
  • Physical presence and oratory are also essentiel but Theirs is so short that his legs barely encircle a horse, while at the Assembly his disagreeably high-pitched voice can hardly be heard.
  • Urbanity is indispensable, he shows off his newly-acquired wealth like the parvenu he is.

Work, intelligence and Marseilles blarney explain his success:

  • He founds the first Opposition newspaper at the end of the 1820's, writes the call that launches the 1830 Revolution, persuades Louis-Philippe to accede to the throne and holds the highest positions during that reign.

  • As head of the conservative opposition he is jailed after Napoleon III's coup d'état and for most of the Second Empire (1851-1870) is retired. He returns to politics as a deputy (in 1868) and is one of the few to oppose the Franco-Prussian war (in July 1870).

  • That lucidity leads to his heading the Third Republic when the Empire implodes (in September 1870). He becomes its President, and holds that position until his death.

But he also... 

  • Commands the brutal repression of a silk workers' revolt in Lyons, France's second largest city (in 1834):


"Let them fire the first shot. Then let them have it." Six hundred people are killed, almost all workers.

  • Orders crushing the Parisian revolt that follows, accompanying the troops himself:

Internet without more information

Advises the commander of the "June" carnage (in 1848):


Internet without more information

  • Inspires this image, where with one foot in the grave he asks Death to wait while he bombards Paris under La Commune:


"O death! Wait a minute more!"


Thiers leads or contributes to
all the massacres of his times except that 
following Napoleon III's take-over in 1851,
when he is in prison.