Tuesday, November 25, 2014

VI.4.3. VICTORIES OF LA COMMUNE


YOUNG MEN WTH NO ADMINISTRATIVE TRAINING KEEP THE CONTINENT'S LARGEST CITY* AFLOAT 

*A million and a half inhabitants 

With minimal resources they manage a city that has not recovered from the draconian siege to which the Prussians add their own,* and is almost immediately at war.

*They let in some goods to pressure Versailles, but the siege is still a handicap.

Fight between the Fédérés and Regular Troops West of Paris by Michel Charles Fichot, 1871, zoom

Three-quarters of the functionaries leave for Versailles with archives, equipment and funds. Their replacements are journalists, craftspeople or blue-collar workers, who are often under 30 and have no plan or governing experience. 

La Presse pendant la Commune Les Amis de la Commune

The men in the foreground have not gone home to sleepMost were in their '30's. They had the energy of youth.

The Commune at City Hall - The Throne Room
 -- Journal universel
Hannah Robinson for The New York Times, March 27, 2026 : zoom

The astonishing victory of Zohan Mamdan (age 34) as Mayor of New York and the will of his young team to transform the city remind of La Commune. 

"We had to manage war, revolution, the administration of a besieged town and reply to citizens' multiple solicitations, all at the same time. Corrupt businessmen and profiteers had no trouble slipping into the lines."
-- Le Banquet des affamés [famished] by Didier Daeninckx, 2012
A novel that follows the sources.

# # #

Thiers's 
"satanic battle plan:" Without functionaries Paris
will have no light or water, sewers will overflow, garbage fill the streets, the dead be unburied: Chaos and epidemics will bring collapse. 
-- Jules Andrieu (below)

 Yet,
 
  • While the American press calls the Communards a “wild, reckless, irresponsible, murderous mobocracy” a pastor says, "I have never seen the streets so well swept since the siege as they were this morning."
 -- American press cited by Heather Cox Richardson, blog of Sept 1 2024.
  Observation, the Reverend William Gibson cited in Paris Babylon by Rupert Christiansen, 1994
'
  • Theaters, restaurants, cafés, museums, schools, the university, scientific research, transportation, go on as usual. 
  • The main change: People from blue-collar suburbs come to wealthy neighborhoods...

The elegant street light, balcony and portal (to the right) show a fashionable street.

    Illustrated London News, print sold on eBay
 "The Poultry-Seller at Palais-Royal, under the Commune"
He wears the guards' uniform

  • Three musical performances are given simultaneously to succor widows and orphans (on May 11). In the background, the sound of cannons.   

Illustrated London News / Gallica, no longer available  

# # #

Among the officials who make the city function: 

-- Notes to Serve for a History of the Commune, 1871, re-ed. 2016 (in French)

Jules Andrieu
Having given night classes to workers brings his appointment. Though he comes from the bottom of the hierarchy his former superiors agree to serve under him, so that public services continue. 

He works 16-17 hours a day, sleeps on a couch and leaves City Hall for personal reasons only four times in 50 days. 

Like the men sleeping through the din in the image at above and Louise Michel saying,"I almost never slept, when I did it was anywhere, or when there was nothing better to do. Many others did the same."


  • The Head of the Postal Services, Albert Theisz, and his auxiliaries 
-- Services Publiques sous la Commune,
ed. Les Amis de la Commune (in French).

Albert Theisz

Versailles blocks communication with Paris to hurt its recovery and keep provincials and soldiers from knowing its realities. Officials remove the plates for printing stamps, to stop communication within the city.

This engraver on bronze, member of the First International, mobilizes auxiliaries to deposit mail in points outside the city. They know they will be arrested if caught.

They distribute all the city mail by April 4 and find a plate to print stamps. 



       # # #
Salaries

  •  5400 francs a year for deputies, 6000 for Delegates (Ministers). 
  • Specialized workers, about 1000 a year.
  • Theisz's predecessor, 71,000. (Thiesz himself refuses the Delegate's extra pay.)
-- Public Services
# # #

Most employees stick to their jobs although they know the risk.
-- Lissagary 

  • The vast majority of postal employees stay in Paris (800 out of 1000), knowing they will be fired if Versailles wins. 
                     -- Public Services
  •  Firemen also remain, though as they are officially part of the army, they can be shot as deserters: That is the fate of the most prominent.  

Guards are thought undisciplined because they want to go home
"to embrace their children, caress their wives, before plunging into the unknown of battle."
-- Vallès

Yet they usually do their duty in spite of the unique absence of sanctions: At worst, they aren't paid.  

# # #

Left to itself, La Commune could have succeeded because:

  • Its ambitions were local. It wanted a federation of communes, not a centralized State.
  • Industrialization was too new for rooted unions or political parties to smother grass-roots energy.
  • It inspired heroism.  

"Long live humanity!"
cried the journalist Jean-Baptiste Millière,
when he was forced to kneel before being shot:
Later revolutionaries say that call inspired them. 
-- An account of his death: Lissagary, Appendix XXI

Engraving after the work of Henri de Montaut, who received the medal of the Legion of Honnor two months later. 
  -- L'Assassinat infâme de Jean-Baptiste Millière, " Les Amis de la Commune
 

Such figures contradict capitalists' assertion
that greed is part of human nature.

*     *     *
Next,
 6.4.4. 




Tuesday, November 18, 2014

VI.4.4. ROOTED


THE SONG "CHERRYTIME" THAT ALL FRENCH PEOPLE KNOW EVOKES THE COMMUNARDS' BRIEF HOPE...

and one of its last lines its blood-soaked end.  



But how short is the season of cherries  
When people, dreaming two by two, 
 gather earrings...  

Le Temps des Cerises ("Cherry Time") by Jean-Baptiste Clément and Philip Dumas, 1990

Cherries of love with dresses
That fall under the leaves like drops of blood
But how short is the season of cherries
When dreamers gather earrings 

Traditional recording by Yves Montand, 1960's
A recent recording by Noir Désir, 2008

Communard Jean-Baptiste Clément wrote the melancholy song about lost love before La Commune. After it he added the line about drops of blood and dedicated the song to "Louise," an ambulance driver met on the last barricade that she refused to leave. He would always reject royalties.

The sound of that barricade's explosion carried as far as Versailles. When Communards imprisoned there heard it, they knew that La Commune was over.
-- Louise Michel

A graphic novel tells its story. It was put to music:
.
     Le Cri du peuple by Jacques Tardi (Castermann, 4 vols. 2001-04), after the novel by Jean Vautrin

La Commune represents the hope of an egalitarian and just democracy and is a major landmark for the left:

Communist Ball, July 13, place de la Commune 
For that site, please read on

           Cergy-Pontoise insoumise
An important leftist party (La France insoumise, "Unbowed France") chose March 18, the day the Commune broke out, to launch its presidential campaign in 2017.

# # #

Commemorating the 150th anniversary

  • On walls where La Commune was strongest and that still lean left:

In the 20th

In the 13th

  • At the church of the Sacré Coeur 

   Ma Commune de Paris
An evocation of the carnage that that the church's builders approved.

# # #

More testimonies:

  • The theater "La Commune:" The name suggests productions that are innovative and thoughtful.

  Zoom
In Aubervilliers, a working-class suburb in the north. Founded in 1965, the first permanent theater in an outskirt announces the evolution these pages describe. 

  • Annual commemorations since 1883, at the wall where the last combattants were shot.

The Mur des Fédérés, in the Père Lachaise cemetery

  • A fresco with figures that are six feet tall near the site of the last barricade...


By QMRK, 2021 / Irina Zwerger

...chosen by popular vote* in 2019

*The participatory budgetParisians' vote to finance urban projects.

Saturday, November 15, 2014

VI.4.5. "FRIENDS OF THE PARIS COMMUNE"

 

AN ASSOCIATION CREATED BY FORMER COMMUNARDS RETURNED FROM EXILE OR DEPORTATION
(IN 1882) 
  
46 rue des Cinq-Diamants,13th
https://www.commune1871.org/

A teacher explains La Commune


# # #

A plaque at Père Lachaise cemetery recalls the shootings.

This is the original. Damaged by the passage of time it was given to the association, which exhibits it in its locale:

To the Commune's fallen,
May 21-28 1871

Volunteers inform the public every weekday afternoon. Some visitors...

"I'll give this to my granddaughter"
(The t-shirt shows Louise Michel)

Railroad-worker militants

# # #

The annual fête presents the epic:
 
Alain Leiblanc

MC Willard

"We used to be alone. 
Now 20 organizations have joined us,"
a volunteer said.

End of this section.

*     *     *

Next section,



Sunday, October 12, 2014

VII.1.3. CONTRADICTORY PANELS OCCUPIED THIS CROSSROAD


ONE NAMED THE SPACE "PLACE DE LA COMMUNE DE PARIS," THE OTHER GAVE PICTURESQUE DETAILS BUT OMITTED LA COMMUNE...

And the battle a few steps away. 

Friends of the Paris Commune put up the "place de la Commune" sign in 2015.

The panel that a right-wing municipality put up toward 2000 :


History of Paris
La Butte-aux-Cailles

Pierre Caille [useless erudition] purchases a vine-covered hillside dominating the Bièvre in 1543. He leaves his name to the small agricultural terrain, whose history is hardly affected by the forced landing of the first hot-air balloon carrying the marquis d'Arlauder and Pilâtre de Rozier in 1783 [useless erudition]. The hilltop is crowned by windmills. One of them remains on this small opening until the 1860's. It also provides stones and clay. Between the Révolution of 1848 and World War I, the Butte aux Cailles is colonized by ragpickers and leather workers.The village without a church is populated by farms, workshops and shops in a spirit of conviviality and freedom. [There is no mention of La Commune.]

That sign was removed and the other more prominently displayed (in 2024)



# # #

Political messages now:  


Liberty for political prisoners!.  

Toward 2022-2024
"Nationalists not welcome"

At the crossroad a minute's walk away:


Toward 2017-2020 

The small, pleasant site
recalls the horrific battle
in its quiet way.  

*    *    *